Review: 'Uncharismatic' Morten Harket and A-ha bid farewell to Nottingham's Trent Arena

Trusted article source icon
Monday, November 22, 2010
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

"THANK you for coming to celebrate 25 years of us making music together." The words of a-ha's Magne Furuholmen as the Norwegian trio played their last ever show in Nottingham before they formally end their quarter of a century association next month.

The Scandinavians have finally decided to call it a day and celebration was a recurring theme of the night. From a brash and loud opening The Sun Always Shines On TV, the band raced through a retrospective set list featuring hits from throughout their long career.

With no new material to share, it was very much an unashamed 'greatest hits' set – even throwing in one or two tracks from their seminal early albums Scoundrel Days and Hunting High And Low.

When a band has a back catalogue as impressive as a-ha – surely one of the most original and high quality pop bands of the 80s – it's tough for the show to be anything but entertaining. Hit after brilliant hit were warmly received by an enthusiastic crowd and there was plenty of screaming as the band performed the likes of Cry Wolf, Manhattan Skyline, I've Been Losing You, Foot Of The Mountain and Crying In The Rain.

In many ways, though, a-ha are a strange live band. They are one of the most competent, slick live acts around entirely despite their reluctance to engage emotionally with their audience. Whilst he may boast a voice which has never sounded better, Morten Harket is also one of the least charismatic front men in pop music.

Most of what little crowd banter there is relies on keyboardist Magne, whilst Harket barely raises a smile during the course of the evening.

Whilst it was yet another in a long series of superb a-ha live shows, I did feel a twinge of disappointment at the lack of any sense of an emotional farewell.

Considering this is the band's final tour, it certainly didn't feel like it.

That's not to say that it wasn't a great show, though. Morten sounded as good as I have ever heard him, and the soaring Stay On These Roads and the brilliant, bombastic Bond theme The Living Daylights were particular highlights. However, by the time the last note of Take On Me had faded away, it was apparent that the fans in the Nottingham audience were much sadder than the band that their 25 year relationship had come to an end.

* Set List:

The Sun Always Shines On TV

Move to Memphis

The Blood That Moves The Body

Scoundrel Days

Stay On These Roads

Manhattan Skyline

Hunting High And Low

The Bandstand

Forever Not Yours

We're Looking For The Whales

Butterfly Butterfly (The Last Hurrah)

Crying In The Rain

Minor Earth Major Sky

The Swing Of Things

Summer Moved On

I've Been Losing You

Foot Of The Mountain

Cry Wolf

Analogue

The Living Daylights

Take On Me

Nick Parkhouse

27
Tweet this article
Report

27 Comments

  • Profile image for beckywheeldon

    by beckywheeldon

    Saturday, July 23 2011, 6:50PM

    “I was second row back and i have to agree that Morten favoured one side of the stage. Having said that it was a fantastic show just as all their shows before. It has always been about the music for Morten and he has always been open about the fact that he does not interact much with the audience. I have some cracking photos and video footage and he does smile and his facial expressions should some interaction.
    I am sure that this final tour was as emotional for the band as it has been for the fans and i for one appreciate the fact that there were no cancellations despite the grief that Morten must have been experiencing following the death of his mother. He is human after all!!
    I hope to continue to hear their music for many years to come.”

  • Profile image for carlingnotts

    by carlingnotts

    Sunday, June 26 2011, 2:58AM

    “Well I saw them in Glasgow afew days later at the secc, and they did sing their latest and last song " Butterfly Butterfly ", shame Nottingham missed it ( me being a Notts man ), A-ha have never been a band to interact and dance around a stage, having seen them on four occasions this final gig did not disappoint, in my eyes the greatest band from the 80's for many reasons. All good things do come to end, and thankfully they did finish on a high note !!!”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Irene, Dumfries

    Monday, November 29 2010, 7:58PM

    “Sub-editors have a lot to answer for! I'm with Tim on this one. This is essentially a good review with a little criticism included, but the headline which poor Mr Parkhouse almost certainly did not write himself gives a completely misleading impression. He's probably mortified that his balanced and honest (from his viewpoint) review has been interpreted so negatively.
    Most long-term a-ha fans know by now that Magne essentially takes the role of frontman when it comes to interacting with the fans, and that's OK. A-ha are doing a huge farewell tour with many concerts, but at any given concert there will be many fans who are seeing the band for their last time, so it's natural the fans might be more emotional about it than the band. A-ha's final farewell to their fans will be in Oslo on 4 December, and that will be hugely emotional for everyone. Heck, even the security staff might shed a tear or two!”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Lou, Nottingham

    Saturday, November 27 2010, 8:43PM

    “I have been a fan since I saw the 'Take on me' video 25 years ago. I went to the Nottingham concert on sunday night and I also saw them at the Concert Hall on their first tour, I thought they were fantastic. Maybe certain peoples comments would have been a little more sympathetic if they had known that Morten's mother passed away on 2nd November.......”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Sean, Derby

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 8:59AM

    “Isn't that the point, there are two sides to a story.

    Nicks review was one side and then there were those of us who enjoyed the concert and didn't see any issues.

    I personally went to listen to the music and see the band, not someone prancing about on stage like a puppet on a string. I wasn't disappointed in what I experienced.

    I accept others views, but at the same time they must accept that others may have a different view.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Tim, Nottingham

    Wednesday, November 24 2010, 6:41PM

    “three quick technical points:

    1) abusing someone inaccurately in print is libel and not slander. It's slander on the web, but this article was originally printed in the paper, so....

    2) Headlines are usually written by sub-editors and not journalists., so don't assume that Parkhouse had anything to do with it.

    3) the job of a reviewer is to express an opinion. You don't have to agree with it.

    What seems to be happening here is that an essentially very positive review has hijacked by a misleading headline that latched onto one comment and a few people (and Sean, don't pretend you can represent the views of everyone there bar the two people you KNOW disagree with you) have got very upset because it wasn't all sunshine and flowers. I'm glad you all enjoyed the gig, but don't get all grumpy because not everyone thought it was AMAZING. I enjoyed it, but thought they were better at the NIA last year. I"m sure Morten has been through a tough time, and this is towards the end of a gruelling tour, but there you are. That's what I thought. I don't really care if the reviewer got free tickets or not: I paid my £50 and I'm entitled to my opinion.

    Oh, and Kings of Leon fan, for me the KoL have been getting steadily worse as they've got more successful, and basically the quality has been down since their second album. They were awesome at Rock City in 2004 though, I'll give you that!

    a-ha, on the other hand have been consistently excellent for years, from Hunting High and Low all the way through to Foot of the Mountain and we'll miss them. Surely we can all agree on that!”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by D, Nottingham

    Wednesday, November 24 2010, 6:38PM

    “@ S.
    Mr Parkhouse paid full price for his ticket (check his twitter stream).

    @ Sean
    The reviewers don't get to choose the headline, the Editor does. And one smart editor indeed has incited 20+ comments, none of which seem to be from Mr Parkhouse.

    All he did was write a balanced review, but because it wasn't sycophantic enough, a few people have taken it upon themselves to start name-calling.

    Would it have hurt Mr Harket to have had a little chat to the audience? We paid a lot to be there, after all.

    The way I see it is that Mr Parkhouse could have been harsher, as I felt the gig came off technically perfect, but was strictly professional and nothing more. We may as well have been in a very big lounge room with a nice sound system for all that was happening up on stage. No one was expecting pyrotechnics or backing dancers, but to not even get a conversation out of the lead singer of a band on their farewell tour does indeed deserve at least a mention in a fair-minded review.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Anastasia, London

    Wednesday, November 24 2010, 5:32PM

    “@ Genghis
    We´re not as bad as we seem, although in my case, given to writing admittedly pathetic posts in an a-ha discussion.
    @ian
    I just thought I´d add a humourless piece of information for no particular reason:
    a-ha have troubled the chart compilers twice in the last two years: last year when Foot of the Mountain reached number 5 in the UK album chart, and some weeks ago when their best-of-compilation reached number 10 in said chart.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by S., Nottingham

    Wednesday, November 24 2010, 5:25PM

    “Does writing a book about 80¿s pop music give you the qualified right to upset true fans and slander someone by saying that they are uncharismatic, no ¿ if however Mr Parkhouse¿s book had been solely dedicated to a-ha then perhaps he could have been justified stating his opinion, but perhaps at the end of his article/opinion. I am a huge fan of a-ha and although I don¿t own every single piece of a-ha memorabilia and have never screamed my way through a concert or tv appearance by a-ha, I am very upset with Mr Parkhouse¿s article; just because it wasn¿t to his taste it is not fair to brand the lead singer as uncharismatic ¿ did Mr Parkhouse pay for his ticket(s)? I think not, so it wasn¿t his actual choice to be there, unlike the fans. It is sad that having the ability to sing and perform LIVE means you are branded as uncharismatic, unlike boring, same sound, predictable, pop processed junk mimed, sorry lip-synchronized, by the likes of Cheryl Cole, Britney, etc, and don¿t forget Roy Orbison.... very boring standing still strumming guitar wearing dark glasses...., not like all these fantastic charismatic performers that can sing upside down whilst drinking a pint of larger and doing the latest Sudoku and ensuring that the audience participate by copying them......; also for a performer to be charismatic, do they (no matter what their age) have to cartwheel around the stage for each and every performance during the long tiring tour, for Mr Parkhouse they obviously do..... (don¿t panic, I appreciate Roy¿s voice/music).”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Kings of Leon Fan, Mapperley

    Wednesday, November 24 2010, 5:17PM

    “What were numptys like A-Ha doing at the Arena the other night, when it should have been a group like the mighty Kings doin their stuff to a sell-out audience.They last played the Arena in December 2008, and are touring the UK
    very soon, but aren't scheduled for Nottingham, which is a travesty. What's up Arena management.? Couldn't we afford them- Rock City in December 2004- Arena in July 2005, then Arena again in December 2007 and 2008. I bet they would have come if their management had been approached.!
    Gutted.!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters