Market Square assault left victim with fractured cheekbone
THREE men involved in a terrifying assault in Nottingham's Old Market Square behaved like "drunken louts", according to a judge.
Victim Phillip Kerr was left with a fractured cheekbone, swelling and bruising after he was punched in the jaw by one of the trio in an unprovoked attack.
Judge Dudley Bennett sent Scott Watson and Christopher Gray to prison for the attack and ordered the third offender, Martin Eddyshaw, to pay £500 compensation to Mr Kerr.
Judge Bennett told Eddyshaw: "Day in and day out in these courts, in the newspapers nationally and locally, you are reading about violence in Nottingham, drunken louts behaving just the way you three did.
"You were out with a couple of louts, quite frankly."
Mr Kerr had been walking alone across the square at 10.40pm on St Patrick's Day, on March 17 this year, when Watson asked him for a cigarette.
Mr Kerr said he did not smoke and carried on walking, leaving Watson to return to his group nearby.
After speaking to them, Watson ran after Mr Kerr with Eddyshaw and Gray. Watson barged into him, Eddyshaw shoved him and Gray punched him in the jaw. All three were sentenced at Nottingham Crown Court for assault causing actual bodily harm.
Judge Bennett said: "This was an unprovoked, gratuitous, drunken, violent attack upon a wholly innocent member of the public."
CCTV of the incident, he said, showed Mr Kerr had done absolutely nothing to justify the attack. Gray, 24, of Hodgkin Close, Clifton, received 15 months in prison.
Watson, 22, of Lindfield Road, Broxtowe Estate, was given 15 months for the assault and nine months consecutively for a robbery the same night. Both offences were admitted.
After the attack on Mr Kerr, Watson took a woman's phone as she sent a text at a bus stop in Queen Street.
Simon Eckersley, in mitigation for Gray and Watson, said both men accepted full responsibility for what they had done.
Eddyshaw, 22, of Allendale Avenue, Aspley, who also pleaded guilty, was given a prison sentence of 12 months, suspended for two years, and a five-month curfew.
Richard Posner, in mitigation, said: "It's clear from what you read about him this behaviour was wholly out of character."









6 Comments
by Ian, Hyson Green
Saturday, September 04 2010, 11:53PM
“Six years ago I was assulted in the city unprovokatably the attackant was never caught and having read the sentences handed in this matter I am somehow relieved that my attackant was never caught because its is an insult to hand such attack with a light sentence and £ 500 compensation, I am sure that the victim will have some psychological problems for a long time to come. The justice is a joke!!!”
by big, brother
Saturday, September 04 2010, 11:45PM
“michael the police let the cctv patrol the streets and rely on collins banners hanging from every lampost proclaiming how safe,clean and proud our city is,
so we dont need to employ coppers at weekends (think of the overtime),
i know we say cctv will protect you,we lied about that,
what we mean is cctv will record your death so we can get some air on crimewatch to try and catch your killers,
dont forget crime only happens to other people, sleep tight (but dont go through the square at night),”
by michael, hyson green
Saturday, September 04 2010, 10:54PM
“And where are the police when you need them. They are always banging on about how many coppers are in town at the weekend but week after week there's more stories like this. Hope the 3 "boys" get what's coming to them, the cowards”
by MM, Notts
Saturday, September 04 2010, 4:36PM
“Bunch of inadequate excuses for men. Takes three of them to pick on another person who didn't provoke them and then they pick on a woman. Real hardmen. Be great to see footage of these morons in prison. Whats the betting they won't be starting any fights there, unless there is someone more vulnerable. Idiots.”
by T, Notts
Saturday, September 04 2010, 12:30PM
“Not Notts, its Britain”
by Nott not, Notts
Saturday, September 04 2010, 8:23AM
“They were drunk, they are louts and they were in Nottingham city centre. How else are they supposed to behave?”