Garry Birtles: FA bosses must not repeat mistakes of past, by overlooking Harry Redknapp for England job
THE FA have already made two of the biggest mistakes in the history of football. They cannot be allowed to make another now.
They should have appointed Brian Clough as England manager, when he was in his pomp.
-

Garry Birtles
My old gaffer would have worked wonders. He was the right man for the job.
He was overlooked.
And, before Fabio Capello was appointed, the bigwigs in blazers dismissed Martin O'Neill, who was also the best man at that time, as a potential candidate.
Now they have to learn from those mistakes.
They absolutely, positively have to appoint Harry Redknapp as the next England manager.
There just isn't another possible candidate for the role.
Yes, in an ideal world, I'd still like my old pal O'Neill to be given an opportunity.
But the fact is that he does not want it. That particular boat has sailed a long time ago.
And even Martin can see that the only man for the job now is Harry.
I feel some sympathy for Capello, because he was badly undermined by some poor decision-making from England's football hierarchy.
I don't have an issue with John Terry having the England captaincy taken off him, while we await the result of his trial over allegations of racism.
But the way the whole thing was handled bordered on comedy.
If that was the step they wanted to take, it should have been done immediately, as soon as it became clear he faced criminal charges, not months down the line.
And Capello should have been involved in those discussions. The decision should not have been made behind his back.
Having said all of that, I am also glad to see him leave, because I don't believe his heart was in the job.
I would not be shocked if he was actually secretly pleased to have escaped the role.
Because I am not convinced he believed England had any chance of achieving anything at the European Championships this summer.
Under his guidance, I am not sure we did.
We are talking about a man who was still struggling with the English language, he never seemed to be fully committed to fully learning the language, which was surely a basic requirement.
He certainly didn't seem to ever grasp the peculiar passions and nuances of the English game. He never quite came to terms with the media or how to properly handle them.
Neither are things that will faze Harry. Heck, the fact that he is favourite for the job now is partly because he is the press favourite.
He knows how to deal with them; how to get his message across.
And that, crucially, is a talent he possesses with the players as well.
He is a motivator, an inspiration. Players like and respect him.
He is not a complex character, he is old school. But to me that is also important. Because it means he has old-fashioned values.
People who regularly read this column will know how much I value that.
There are too many players in the modern era who are more concerned about how many Rolex watches and Aston Martins they have than how many England caps.
They need a manager who will remind them exactly how special it should be every time they wear the three lions on their chests.
Harry has already stated that being England manager would be the very pinnacle of his profession.
I am sure he will instil the same level of appreciation among his players.
The only difficult decision that has to be made before the tournament kicks off in the summer is over who should be captain.
Obviously Terry is out of contention. Rio Ferdinand is a player on the wane.
Frank Lampard's time also looks to have passed, in terms of him being one of the first names on the team sheet – which is a basic requirement of your skipper.
Steven Gerrard's recent injury record leaves some doubt over him . . . so where does that leave us?
I cannot overstate the importance of John McGovern's role as a leader in our Forest side that was fortunate enough to enjoy so much success.
He was a figurehead, a driving force for us, on and off the pitch.
It was the same with the great Liverpool sides during that same era. They had the likes of Phil Thompson and Graeme Souness.
These were hard, inspirational men. People who dragged their sides through anything that came between them and success.
That is what England are missing now. There are no truly inspirational characters in that dressing room.
Which is why it is so critical that they appoint a manager who can provide some of those qualities himself.
And that man is Harry.
Steve Cotterill believes he has added some toughness and steel to his Nottingham Forest side, with the signings he has made over the past week or so.
And I certainly wouldn't relish going toe-to-toe with George Elokobi, because he is a man mountain. A beast.
But what Forest need at the minute is not physical toughness, but mental strength.
Cotterill was right to add depth to his back four ahead of anything else, because Forest were desperately short of numbers.
But, while it will do no harm to have a few hard men in there, what matters most is that they have the mental toughness to get through what is going to be a real battle, between now and the end of the season.
They need to defend bravely and have the confidence to take chances when they come their way. When you are in a relegation fight, no qualities are more important than that.







4 Comments
by flipflopper
Sunday, February 12 2012, 3:08PM
“So Garry you agree with the FA do you?
"I don't have an issue with John Terry having the England captaincy taken off him, while we await the result of his trial over allegations of racism."
So you agree with condemning him before the trial do you? In this country a person is considered innocent until proven guilty. It is people like you who will get him hanged, with comments like that. You and others in the media, are in a position to influence the jury before the trial ever takes place. It matters not whether he is innocent, let's convict him anyway, you numpty.
As to the case I had never heared of Anton Ferdinand before all of this in the papers. I knew Rio had a younger brother who played football, but had know idea what his first name was; now everybody has heared of him. What a marvellous way to go from obscurity overnight. His agent is doing a tremendous job for him.
See that the two faced Fergusson is still scoring points on the racism front, ManU v Liverpool. I remember a few years ago he tried to get the F.A. to nail Psycho for alledged racist remarks to Paul Ince, but when Schmeichel made similar remarks to Ian Wright, it was alright, because that sort of thing happens in football, and nothing racist is meant by it.”
by tfaulkner
Sunday, February 12 2012, 2:38PM
“While Cotterill has addressed the lack of cover in defence he has not addressed the problems Forest have scoring goals. Tudgay, Miller, Blackstock, McGoldrick, Derbyshire, Harewood-none are scoring and time is running out. We need to win games not hope for a 0-0 or 1-1 at best. A left winger and a fox in the box are still major priorities.”
by AcapulcoAngus
Saturday, February 11 2012, 12:00PM
“Apparently Harry Redknapp has told the FA that he will do the england job part time, cash in hand no questions asked. know what I mean? know what I mean?”
by redarb
Saturday, February 11 2012, 8:37AM
“Let's not fool ourselves. England will never win another major trophy when over 50% of the premiership players are made up foreigners.
Whist it is great for fans of clubs to see some of the worlds best players week in and week out, it harms our national team as the pool of players available is drastically reduced.
If more english players played abroad that would be addressed slightly but, and I can only suspect that greed and pay is the reason, there are next to none of the top british players playing overseas.
Having said all of that, perhaps, just perhaps, Harry is the right man for the England job. Until he took over at Spurs he had a good record at turning pigs ears into silk purses at Bournemouth, Southampton and Portsmouth.”