Debate on gay blood donors splits Labour

Trusted article source icon
Monday, June 21, 2010
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

CALLS for gay men to be allowed to give blood has prompted the largest rebellion in Nottingham City Council's ruling Labour Group for 15 years.

A motion debated by the full council called on it to write to the National Blood Service asking it to scrap its "discriminatory and outdated policy towards gay and bisexual men".

The NHS National Blood Service does not allow "men who have ever had sex with men" to give blood because, it claims, there is a greater risk of infections being passed to patients who need the blood.

Campaigners argue the lifetime ban is unnecessary and that accepting donations from gay men who are HIV negative or from those who have had protected sex, would boost vital blood supplies.

But a motion debated by the council divided Labour members. The group's leadership did not want to back the motion put forward by the Liberal Democrats. Behind the scenes there were sharp exchanges between Labour councillors.

One told the Post: "Several members wanted us to just vote for the motion, but were bounced into having an amendment. It ended in rebellion."

In the vote, three members of the council's executive, Councillors David Mellen, Jane Urquhart, and David Liversidge, along with a clutch of backbenchers, all abstained.

Councillor Mellen spoke in favour of the main motion.

But Labour's portfolio holder for adult care, Councillor Eunice Campbell, and Councillor Emma Dewinton, moved an amendment removing the passage about discrimination, and sat down without applause.

Councillor Campbell argued that a review of the criteria governing blood donation had begun under the previous Labour government and the council should consult with local MPs when the result of that work was published.

She told the Post: "We're not saying there's not discrimination against gay and bisexual people, and I am saying there is a review and we should wait."

Ms Campbell said she would wait for scientific opinion before deciding whether the blood donation ban was discriminatory.

Meanwhile, Liberal Democrat councillor Alex Foster, who moved the motion claiming discrimination, was cheered by Labour members.

Mr Foster, who is gay, said he was "disappointed" that Labour failed to support his motion, and he was surprised the group had split.

"The Labour group in Nottingham is almost Stalinist in the way they observe their whip," he said.

"Labour councillors always vote together, en bloc. They discuss things privately in group, decide on a common line, and then stick to it rigidly.

"At least five Labour councillors sat on their hands, and looked uncomfortable."

They included three frontbenchers and a civic councillor, the Sheriff of Nottingham, Councillor Penny Griggs.

Councillor Andrew Price, leader of the Conservative group, said: "This is important. Block discrimination against homosexuals is outdated and wrong and Councillor Foster was saying this needs to be sorted out.

"The Labour councillors who rebelled thought the group position was completely unnecessary."

37
Tweet this article
Report

37 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by kate, nottingham

    Monday, March 28 2011, 7:59PM

    “This "right on" council are beginning to irritate.Men who have sex with men have a high chance of contracting aids,so it seems criminal to me to press for blood from this group to be used.I certainly wouldn,t want it.As a teenager,I had jaundice and was not able to donate blood for years,which was a disappointment for me.I didn,t demand that it was against my rights to be a donor,I accepted it as a reasonable precaution.
    Nottingham council should address more important issues like revealing their expenditure figures.After all,if they want equality across the board,nottingham citizens should be afforded the same treatment as every other council tax payer in the country.
    I would also be interested to know who paid the bill for the recent Council House banquet ,to honour those who had worked to promote the rights of gay people in the city.
    My new council tax bill arrived today which is increased from last year.
    I work hard for my money,I don,t want Nottingham city Council wasting it.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Ted, Notts

    Wednesday, June 23 2010, 9:28AM

    “If the liberals who so readily defend the right of gays to donate blood also defend the right of prostitutes, heroin addicts and people from countries like South Africa to give blood also, I will at least admire their consistency of idiocy.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by tim, the park

    Wednesday, June 23 2010, 8:42AM

    “Marlon... Are you sure your name isn't moron?”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Marlon, uk

    Tuesday, June 22 2010, 10:47PM

    “I hear what your all saying about the aids being passed on,what worries me is the thought of becoming a dale winton after a drop of the stuff,no ones mentioned that disease yet have they.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by j, leic

    Tuesday, June 22 2010, 8:50PM

    “What prey tell is an "English story"??!!!!! Surely any story about an event that has taken place in England is an English story?? Care to explain what on earth you are on about?

    And no, I'm not a Labour party activist; my current job doesn't allow me to be.

    Finally, a project I am currently involved in is around improving the educational attainment of white working class boys. How terribly racist!”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters