Council rejects street smoking ban

Trusted article source icon
Friday, December 12, 2008
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

A BAN on smoking on city streets will not be considered by Nottingham City Council because it could breach human rights laws.

Councillors put forward the idea in September to combat the numbers of smokers standing outside buildings.

They recommended Nottingham City Council's director of performance and scrutiny investigate the possibility of a bye-law to control street smoking.

But council officer Julie Rankin has ruled the law - which would apply only to Nottingham - would not be "appropriate".

She said: "A ban on smoking in all streets would be subject to challenge by human rights legislation and may prove difficult to enforce."

32
Tweet this article
Report

32 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Teen From Notts, H.Vale

    Sunday, December 14 2008, 2:24PM

    “What about my human rights? I dont want to breathe in the fag smoke...”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by tug wilson, nottingham

    Saturday, December 13 2008, 10:02PM

    “It is time for Nottingham Landlords to do what many others are doing around the country and Ban their local MPs who voted for a total smoking ban and ban local councillors who support the ban in pubs and clubs,name and shame them for backing this ill thought out law.as the Rev JP has said in the EU you still have a free choice.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Zippy, Notts

    Saturday, December 13 2008, 10:34AM

    “Soon we will all have to wear a compulsory uniform with 'I love the City Council' on it!
    People who refuse to wear it will be arrested.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Rev.J.P.Cotterill-Attaway, Hyson Green

    Saturday, December 13 2008, 10:34AM

    “Of course...it all makes sense now.....you go into a pub, light up...get fined, so you then step outside to finish it....get fined, you then stamp out the cigerette and then get fined for littering!

    As for the election, originally, the Health Bill 2006 was going to let Pubs and Clubs decide whether they were smoking/non-smoking or have designated areas..in accordance with an arrangement between the Government and the Licensee Trade in 2001...however, by January 2006, less than 5% of all public houses were smoke-free, obviously the government didn't like this....
    Of course,they have left themselves a loophole so that the 'national authority' can, at a later date, designate some venues as smoking venues....of course, this will be used in the next General Election as blackmail.

    The Smoking Pan in public was to bring Britain in line with the EU...however, only Britain and Eire have a total ban, Germany have decided that ANY ban would be unconstitutional while Yugoslavia seem to have all but refused to consider a ban...the rest of the EU allow bars etc. to designate areas for smokers or to have smoking/non-smoking rooms.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Have a Go Hero, nottingham

    Friday, December 12 2008, 10:54PM

    “Here is some information for the anti smoking brigade.

    It a well documented fact the Alcohol abuse costs the Helath System far more than smoking does.
    It cost the tax payer far more to treat people with drink related heath problmes and with other problems related to drinking and Alcoholism than it does with illness's due to smoking.
    If you dont believe me do the research like I did”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by TREV FAIRMINER, Watching

    Friday, December 12 2008, 10:47PM

    “Hard luck Collins and cronies. No doubt you were rubbing your hands together again, thought you might have another nice little earner. Dont forget the three R's Revenue Revenue Revenue. How much would the fine have been for Smoking in the Street ? The people of Nottingham are at last on to you. Why are you not taking notice of the Citezens of Nottingham ? We all no you read these comments, don't we Mr Collins. Bring on the next Local Elections. Get your bags packed !”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by wurrows, Nottingham

    Friday, December 12 2008, 9:33PM

    “I totally agree with the ban on smoking in public. Totally - but on one condition - NuLabour control freeks are also totally banned from public appearance. Idiots!”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Steve, Gunthorpe Pie

    Friday, December 12 2008, 8:59PM

    “Anyone got a light?”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by tug, nottingham

    Friday, December 12 2008, 8:38PM

    “I would like to say some common sense has been shown,but with the total smoking ban still in force i dont think so,the smoking ban has been a massive disaster not only to Pubs and Clubs but also to the Country with NO health benefits at all,like other Countries smoking rates have gone up since the ban and so as unemployment as a direct result of the ban,you would have to be a fool to call the smoking ban a success in any way,Smokers are Voters and at the next election Labour will be out,it is time for people to have a free choice,smoking and non smoking venues then there would be no need for smokers to stand outside on the paths smoking a legal product.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by M.J.J, Notts

    Friday, December 12 2008, 8:31PM

    “Fair enough. I'm beginning to think that people know something I don't!
    To be honest, I tend to think that if people think this is such a dreadful place to live they are a bunch of losers for staying here.
    That won't make me many friends either Ah well
    "I have my boooks and my poetry to defend me" remember that?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters