Calderwood as disappointed as anyone at his Forest failure
WHEN Neil Warnock was sacked as manager of Notts County, he made a quick phone call to the Evening Post offices, swiped a bottle of vintage champagne from the Meadow Lane board room and insisted the photographer click away as he raised a glass to toast his success.
It was a typical Warnock moment. It was a statement; a declaration – I may have been sacked, but I am still a success.
-

ALL TOO MUCH: Forest fans leave early as the Reds put in a dismal performance against Doncaster
There was no such a brash or public departure from the City Ground for Colin Calderwood; merely a phone call to politely confirm he was not in the mood to talk about his departure.
While he has also had some notable successes on the opposite bank of the River Trent, the Scot was in no mood to reflect on his achievements, only to lament his failures.
His disappointment was not merely rooted in the fact that he had lost his job, but in the fact he had failed to do the job to the standards he desired.
He will view his time at Nottingham Forest as a job unfinished. He is not the sort of man to shout from the rooftops, he will not focus on the triumph of promotion from League One, but on the frustrations and failures that followed.
Calderwood has paid the price for one thing – bad results.
Four wins from 25 Championship matches had an inevitable, unavoidable consequence.
It is not that football has a short memory. It is, in fact, quite the opposite. It is the fact that the cold, clear recollection of life in the third tier remains only too fresh in the mind.
And, while it came at the expense of the man who had helped them escape that footballing wasteland, the hierarchy at the club were not willing to risk allowing it to happen again.
Calderwood helped them achieve one objective, by steering them out of League One. But for the next – avoiding relegation – they will turn to somebody else.
While Warnock made a point of reminding people of his successes, the fact that Calderwood is unlikely to do the same does not mean they are not worthy of recognition.
As he empties his office in the bowels of the Main Stand, he will doubtless run through the same things that everyone who has ever lost their job does.
What went wrong? What could have I have done differently? With the benefit of hindsight, there are numerous areas that can easily be criticised.
A lack of experience in the side is an obvious one, given that Forest have frequently fielded a team with an average age under 23.
And naivety, not just in defence, but across the pitch, has often cost the Reds dear.
There is no questioning their ability. What they have sometimes lacked is knowledge and experience. Forest put their faith in youth and were repaid with the kind of mistakes that come through innocence.
But, at the same time, it is players like Chris Cohen, Kelvin Wilson, Lewis McGugan and Joe Garner who will provide the foundation stone for the future, and they were all players signed by, or brought through the ranks, by Calderwood.
Equally, people will point to tactical failures, to games such as the one against Norwich City a month ago, when Forest not only failed to beat a side reduced to ten men, but also failed to ever find an approach that even made them look capable of doing so.
Last night's result was the straw that broke the camel's back, but Forest's inconsistency had seen the poor creature unsteady on it's feet for some time.
Too often they would follow up promising performances with displays from the opposite end of the spectrum.
Time and again optimism would swell as they set high standards, only for the bubble to burst following insipid displays from the opposite end of the spectrum.
Last night was the prime example, as Doncaster, a side who had never managed to score more than a single goal in a game this season, ran riot at the City Ground.
Calderwood has failed to find the best way to harness the abilities of his squad in the Championship. He had collected most of the pieces required to form a successful side at this level, but he has failed to put them together in the right order.
But, like Warnock at Notts County back in the early 90s, Calderwood is still equipped to have a bright future.
The success he achieved at Forest – and previously at Northampton Town – is unlikely to be his last in football. As a team, Nottingham Forest were at times let down by their lack of experience, but as a manager, perhaps Calderwood was too.
He has paid the price for that. And, in the cold light of day, it was a difficult, but unsurprising decision that had to be made.
And, while his Forest career has not ended on the note he would have liked, his learning curve is likely to continue elsewhere.
For Forest, that is irrelevant; the time for sentiment has passed.
What counts now is not Calderwood's future, but Forest's.
Billy Davies, the ex-Derby manager, is the man believed to have been lined up for the task of steering Forest to survival.
But, for Forest fans, the name on the manager's door would count for little as long as, on the final day of the season, he has done enough to ensure that Forest finish out of the bottom three.
If that happens, then the champagne will be flowing in the manager's office at the City Ground.







5 Comments
by brian, nottm
Saturday, December 27 2008, 8:25PM
“Calderwood has never been popular since the first kick of his first match in charge and yet he has left the club in a stronger position than he found it. 2 classic mistakes on Boxind Day led to his downfall. He changed a winning team. Players at this level need consistency of selection and position. He used all his subs too early. Twice in key matches he has left us playing with 10 men. In spite of his unpopularity, Colin has been unfailingly polite to the press, has never publically blamed the ref or berated a poor performing player, but he had to go. We need a manager whose tactical style is to play to win not to avoid losing.”
by S, Wilford
Saturday, December 27 2008, 9:04AM
“So what did CC swipe from the Forest Board Room booze cabinet????
Our next manager needs his independence from Nigel Doughty. Over the last 10 years, Nigels' yes men have all failed.”
by David Morgan, Grantham
Saturday, December 27 2008, 1:41AM
“If you are going to pre-prepare an obituary like this, I suggest proof reading it first. The match happened in the afternoon, not the night. Also, why is Calderwood not reflecting on his successes, just lamenting his failures? How do you know this if he refused to talk to you about it? Poor article all round NEP.”
by Michael R Smithson, Cambridgeshire
Saturday, December 27 2008, 1:09AM
“John Pemberton is a winner who instills confidence, has demonstrated tactical ability and has the necessary knowledge of all Forest's young stars, McGugan, Moloney, Reid, Byrne, Thornhill etc. many of whom have played, or do play, for his ever successful reserve team. He and they are Forest's future and he knows when to play them, and where !
Colin Calderwood is a good bloke, and tried hard, I thank him for his efforts.
Please Forest don't now replace him with a 'name', trust John Pemberton please !”
by alan wood, Isla Margarita
Friday, December 26 2008, 10:32PM
“Maybe now we can dispose of chambers,wilson,and lynch.
Restore Breckin to his place as Captain and move forward. Not Davies !! Not Ince !!
Ideally buy out BRIAN LAWS Contract .He would be the fans choice.
Initially put Pemberton in charge !! The players are used to winning games under him and respect him. Gary johnson is another popular choice!!”