Blinded after a single punch

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

A QUANTITY surveyor was left blind and severely disabled after he was knocked to the ground by a single punch.

Brian Hogan went home to bed and fell asleep after being hit – but by the following morning he was unconscious.

Doctors discovered he had suffered bruising and bleeding to his brain and a skull fracture from the fall.

He was in intensive care and there were fears he would not survive.

Six months on, Mr Hogan is being cared for at Linden Lodge Neuro Rehabilitation Unit at Nottingham City Hospital.

His father said his son was reliant on nursing staff but still had the ability to cry "giant tears from eyes that can't see anymore".

Mr Hogan's attacker, Martin Slack, is starting a jail sentence of two years and three months after he admitted causing grievous bodily harm to 33-year-old Mr Hogan.

Nottingham Crown Court heard Mr Hogan had been to @d2 club in Lower Parliament Street in the city centre with friends.

They were heading back to Mr Hogan's when Slack asked if he could join them. Mr Hogan, who did not know Slack, checked with his group.

One said "no", which appeared to be the catalyst for what happened next.

Slack, who had drunk nine to 10 pints, pushed and pulled Mr Hogan before he punched him hard to the face.

"It's clear he was unable to break his fall and fell backwards hard on to the pavement," said Laura Dawes, prosecuting.

One of the group jumped between the defendant and Mr Hogan. He asked Slack why he had done it, to which he replied, "he was rude to me".

Mr Hogan was unconscious for two minutes.

He was treated at the scene by paramedics but declined an offer to go to hospital, believing the injuries were cuts and bruises.

"The victim, to all intents and purposes, was walking around and talking normally," added Miss Dawes.

"At that stage the victim was not reporting any pain, dizziness or nausea."

Slack, 34, of Charles Street, Leabrooks, Alfreton, Derbyshire, was arrested and identified by witnesses.

He wiped away tears as the court was told how Mr Hogan had made a statement from his hospital bed for the judge.

In it Mr Hogan said Slack should be made to realise that "you don't solve problems by violence or by hitting people".

"I would like him to be punished to learn from his mistakes," he said.

Mr Justice David Clarke said the offence carried a maximum five-year prison sentence after a contested trial.

The single punch had not been delivered with any intent to do really serious injury.

"No one present thought it would do really serious injury. But it caused Mr Hogan to fall to the ground and to bang his head on the pavement."

He also said Mr Hogan had cognitive difficulties, but his intellectual capacity was essentially preserved.

After the hearing, Detective Sergeant Justine Wilson said: "This incident shows how one reckless and violent act can have the most devastating consequences on a life."

rebecca.sherdley@nottinghameveningpost.co.uk

38
Tweet this article
Report

38 Comments

  • Profile image for nottspal

    by nottspal

    Saturday, October 08 2011, 2:06AM

    “I know the guy that dealt the blow and I can tell you all, it's completely out of character for him.... H is a gentle, kind man and I believe that the drink was to blame for this tragic consequence.

    It was quite obvious from the trial that "Brian" refused any further treatment and was not feeling dizzy or confused etc etc..... which seems to suggest that the drunken punch was not the cause of the damage. The guilty plea shows the offender's remorse but it is clear it was the fall on the pavement that caused the damage.

    Read the facts and get off the band wagon .........................”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by denyse, Case Manager for Transfer

    Thursday, March 18 2010, 9:24PM

    “Anybody commenting on this case, that does not know or have not met Brian or the Hogan Family, has no right to judge the victim, attacker or the case.

    The consequences are what they are, whether intended or not.

    Brians positivity and personality has made it some bit easier on his family, but this mans life will never be the way it was, so please, avoid printing of your judgement unless you have been and seen the result of your so called "one drunken punch".

    An angry, family friend & key worker.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by friend, Leabrooks

    Sunday, March 14 2010, 3:10PM

    “It's about time the true facts about the case came out, that the person who he hit called him a paedo a few times and thought he would be hit and he punched him first”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Bill Lawrenson, Keyworth

    Thursday, March 11 2010, 7:28PM

    “"drink wine" you still don't get it. The law dictates what penalty a judge can impose and the mitigating factors to be taken into account. in arriving at a penalty which will not be overturned on appeal. Whilst the impact of the head against the pavement was a consequence of the blow to the face it would not be regarded as an intentional consequence that could be foreseen. A bad and vicious unwarranted assault with tragic consequences but not one in which the judge can disregard the legal niceties and deal out revenge.

    As regards boxers wearing gloves they still manage to knock their opponent out by imparting a severe shock to the brain and have been known to cause severe and sometimes fatal injuries. I am sure that the gloved hand of a champion boxer is capable of far more impact damage than a drunk would normally deliver.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Andyman, Derbys

    Thursday, March 11 2010, 6:26PM

    “Why do they wear cloves, just in case the referee is a vampire.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article