Birtles: Forest must sign players now

Trusted article source icon
Saturday, June 20, 2009
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

LET me present you with a few facts. Since the last week in May – almost a month ago – Nottingham Forest have made concrete bids for three players.

They have offered £1m for David McGoldrick, around £700,000 for Paul McKenna and a seven-figure sum for Matt Mills, the Doncaster defender.

Beyond that, supposedly, they have targeted Dexter Blackstock, who it was thought they had agreed a fee for with QPR before he came on loan, Chris Gunter, the Spurs defender, and Joel Lynch, the Brighton man who spent the majority of last season at the City Ground.

All three players have publicly expressed their desire to come to Forest with Gunter, in fact, almost begging for the chance to return.

It is the same story with Gary McSheffrey, who is fighting to prove his fitness at Birmingham – but who is a great talent at Championship level.

And perhaps, to a lesser extent, with Rob Jones, the Hibs captain, who is said to be keen on a move south of the border.

But how many of these players have signed, as we come to the start of the week when some of the squad are due to report back for pre-season training?

How many of these bids have been successful?

Not a single one.

Yes, it is the worst kept secret in football that Forest have signed Dele Adebola on a free transfer from Bristol City.

But, while I believe he will have a role to play next season, with respect, he alone is not going to transform Forest from a side that struggled against relegation into one that can challenge in the top half of the table.

They need more than that.

I realise that, by saying this, I am hardly making some sort of grand revelation. There is not a single Forest fan out there who does not realise this.

And nobody will be more certain of that fact than Billy Davies himself, because he is not an idiot.

I am absolutely certain that he will have drawn up a list of targets for the summer, because he is an experienced manager.

And, through what has been made public, it is clear that Forest have made an effort to sign some of those he has targeted.

Well, to be blunt, it is imperative that they try a little harder. Why?

Yes, it would be good to have the basis of the squad together by the time they report back for training.

But, more significant than that is the simple fact that, if they rest on their laurels for too long, they are going to lose out.

Yes, there were a large number of players who were keen on returning to Forest after coming here on loan.

It does seem that Davies – and probably Colin Calderwood before him – has made it a good place to work, as a player.

But there is a difference between a player wanting to come and his club allowing him to, as we seem to be finding out.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that Nigel Doughty has been stung by some of the reckless spending he allowed some previous managers to indulge in.

And I am not about to slaughter the man who has ploughed so much into Forest in an effort to make the club a success again.

But, good intentions aside, there is now a real danger that some of the players Forest have targeted will end up going elsewhere.

Newcastle are interested in Blackstock and a string of clubs, including Newcastle and Boro, are hot on the heels of Gunter.

McSheffrey will have a queue of clubs after him, as will, in all likelihood, McGoldrick.

Mills is being watched by Birmingham, who want to bolster their squad for the Premiership.

And McKenna might just decide he wants to stay at Preston.

Forest's proud history does make them a positive attraction at this level of the game. Players will still want to play for them, because of the proud name of the club.

But that will only take you so far.

And I am afraid there is a stark reality that Forest may find themselves having to face in the near future.

Given the choice of playing for Doncaster, Preston or even QPR, many players would find it an easy decision to come to Forest.

But, when you find yourselves in a battle with the likes of Newcastle, Middlesbrough and West Brom for the pick of the players in the Championship, you do not have the luxury of being able to hesitate or play a patient game.

If players want to sign for you, get them signed.

Otherwise, we are in danger of seeing a repeat of January, when not a single one of the players Davies wanted was actually signed.

Of course, Forest could prove me wrong by making a couple of signings in the next 24 hours.

But this is one occasion when I would be happy to eat some humble pie.

Because Forest need new players if they are to survive next season.

And I desperately want to see that happen.

20
Tweet this article
Report

20 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Tricky, The Capital

    Friday, June 26 2009, 4:35PM

    “John....
    The worst letter anyone has ever entered on to these pages.
    ABSOLUTE GARBAGE, ever word.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Tricky, The Capital of the East Miodlands

    Friday, June 26 2009, 4:32PM

    “Played Mardy and Anthony”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Anthony Heathcote, Nottingham

    Thursday, June 25 2009, 6:34PM

    “i agree billy davies is no idiot. but you cant say were not trying to sign players because you arnt at the training ground or stadium 24/7 r u. weve made another bid for matt mills who is a quality player. mcgoldrick has neally singed. blackstock is a working progress. camp is pretty much done and dusted and gunter will come for another year on loan. it is all so reported that we will make a bid for Ciacedo of man city so we actually are making progress in the transfer market. all the loanies will probably come as will mckenna and id imagine a load more players”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Mardy, Nottingham

    Sunday, June 21 2009, 1:23PM

    “Mikeyboy, do you have nothing better to do with your sad existence than sit refreshing the pages of the evening post waiting to criticise other people's opinions (by the way it's patience). If Nigel Doughty hadn't bailed Forest out since he became chairman then where would we be now?? Bankrupt, like Southampton more than likely or worse. You can't officially purchase anyone until July 1st, so lets see what happens then. Birtles doesn't know everything that goes on behind the scenes. Players and managers are now returning from holidays so I fully expect things to pick up between now and the end of July. We've all had to go through the bad times, not just yourself, so stop feeling hard done to, renew your season ticket (if you've actually got one) and support your team.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Barry, Stapleford

    Sunday, June 21 2009, 1:03PM

    “Gary of Arnold I would dearly love to think your thinking was correct but I just cannot agree, I just hope I am proved wrong.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article