Nurse involved in baby's salt solution overdose death is under investigation

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, November 25, 2010
Profile image for This is Nottingham

This is Nottingham

A NURSE, who accidentally gave a baby a fatal overdose of salt solution, is also being investigated for posting a picture of herself asleep at work on the internet.

Staff nurse Louisa Swinburn allegedly posted a picture of herself asleep next to baby Samuel McIntosh's cot on a social networking site.

She is now being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council and has been dismissed from her job at the Queen's Medical Centre.

Nottingham Coroners' Court heard yesterday that Samuel died after a "dreadful mistake" at the QMC. The four-month-old was born prematurely on March 1, weighing just 1lb 4oz.

He suffered from breathing problems and a perforated bowel, but the inquest heard that by June 6 he weighed more than 6lb and "was starting to hold his own", according to neonatologist Dr Stephen Wardle. Following surgery on his abdomen his salt levels dropped and he had to be put on a drip.

But instead of the 5ml he was prescribed, he was actually given 50ml. This caused Samuel, of the Arches, Mansfield, to become dehydrated, lose a lot of weight and caused irreparable damage to his brain. He died on July 7.

The inquest heard that Nurse Swinburn and Sister Karen Thomas were involved in measuring out the solution.

Sister Thomas said: "I remember very clearly what I was supposed to do. I can't remember at any point being uncertain. I don't know how this happened."

Both women said they didn't know how the mistake had occurred.

They said they had been interrupted once as they drew up the mixture when a doctor asked Nurse Swinburn about another patient, but they hadn't stopped the procedure of making up the solution.

Returning a narrative verdict, Notts Coroner Dr Nigel Chapman said: "There's no doubt that a dreadful mistake took place but drug errors are more common than we know. In this case there were two people that made a drug error because of distraction by others.

"Samuel died from complications of an overdose of sodium. This was drawn up incorrectly and administered by two nurses."

Sister Thomas still works at the QMC but has been removed from clinical duties that involve direct patient care. Nurse Swinburn has been dismissed for gross misconduct.

Both women are now being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council in relation to the incident.

It emerged after the inquest that Nurse Swinburn also faces allegations that she was sleeping on duty and posted a picture of herself at Samuel's bedside on a website.

Since Samuel's death Nottingham University Hospitals Trust (NUH) has changed procedures in the high dependency unit.

Speaking after the inquest, Paul Balen, who represented the family, said: "It's a huge tragedy that the magnificent work of all the doctors and staff at the QMC with the progress that Samuel made was undermined by the gross negligence of two nurses.

"The family regret that the coroner felt unable to return a verdict of unlawful killing."

In a statement released after the verdict, Dr Stephen Fowlie, Medical Director for Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, extended 'sincere sympathies' and apologised unreservedly for the failings.

He said: "We have changed the way salt solutions are used and given to ensure that these mistakes aren’t repeated. We have new guidance to minimise the need for concentrated salt solution, changed the infusion prescription chart on the neonatal unit and introduced a ‘tabard system’ to ensure nurses are not interrupted when administering drugs.

“We have remained in contact with Sam’s parents throughout the investigation and have met with them on several occasions. We appreciate that we cannot change what happened or compensate for the loss of their baby, and we are determined there will be no repeat of our mistakes.”

15
Tweet this article
Report

15 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Bill Lawrenson, Keyworth

    Friday, November 26 2010, 10:27PM

    “Neil those were the qualities that your and my parents taught us as important from an early age and the need for qualifications came when we had absorbed those basic principles as well as learning to write and acquire living skills. There is a lot to be said for their foresight.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by neil, hucknall

    Friday, November 26 2010, 5:30PM

    “thankyou for your support Bill....

    I really believe that our children(as part of their education) should be told that caring, mutual respect, & attitude are at least as important as qualifications..

    But until (if ever) the people who run things see it that way, then our children will just grow up knowing that qualifications are the main(or only) criteria for success in life.. & the caring, mutual respect, & attitude aren,t very important(if at all)..

    neil, hucknall”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Bill Lawrenson, Keyworth

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 11:26PM

    “Neil you have got it right. Few of us are in a position to make mistakes that can be fatal but we all make mistakes because we are human. The two nurses are going to have to live with this mistake for the rest of their lives because they are in a profession where a moments inattention can be fatal.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by neil, hucknall

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 8:14PM

    “Human beings will make mistakes sometimes, we all do dont we?.. But, in any job we are employed to do, we should do it to the best of our ability..

    & the more important the job is (such as with the NHS), every employee needs to care about their efforts.. Caring about & respecting other people is more important than what qualifications a person has got (in my opinion)..

    But that,s not how a person is assessed for a job in our society.. Qualifications/certificates etc.etc. are the be all & end all most of the time.. & that includes everyone from top management down..

    Caring, mutual respect, & attitude aren,t considered to be mportant enough... If they were, I believe there would be less mistakes made that kill, neglect or cause harm to other people..

    neil, hucknall”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Andyman, Derbys

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 7:16PM

    “When a nurse engages in such stupid practices when she is being investigated, we have to question her abilities to do her job properly.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Steve, Notts

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 6:35PM

    “It seems clear both nurses were supposed to be checking the dose encase one got it wrong. It's like everything else in life when routine comes into play people just assume it¿s correct because 999 times out of a thousand it is. The one who made the sulution up did it wrong and the one who was supposed to check it didn't bother.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by arrogance and complacency, in the NHS

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 6:24PM

    “Exactly. It's a pity someone had to die before they found out that their procedures were trash. Why are we always so good in hindsight? Because there are no forward thinking people in power, they are all reactive thinkers these days, never proactive. A pretty dangerous and arrogant attitude to take when we're talking about people's health and lives.”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by MD, Nottingham

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 4:59PM

    “If the hospital have felt the need to change their procedures around this then surely that suggests that they are at fault rather than the nurses?”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by Dr House, hucknall,,U,S.A

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 4:50PM

    “just to think this lady was walking over the sahara desert to raise funds for the anti natal clinic when her own baby had health probs,,cant win some times !!!”

  • Profile image for This is Nottingham

    by concerned, parent

    Thursday, November 25 2010, 4:34PM

    “in this modern blame culture there is no such thing as tragic accident, if a parent had done this they would be in prison by now,”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters