Alan Simpson MP: More al-Ikea than al Qaida!
The Labour MP for Nottingham South on the weekend's alleged planned protests at Ratcliffe-on-Soar power station
THE police 'swoop' on climate change protesters in Nottingham had an air of the surreal about it. Some 200 police officers, dozens of dogs and a calvacade of police vans descended on a school site in the dead of the night, to conduct Britain's largest pre-emptive arrest in living memory.
-

Clean-up after the police action
Neighbours thought it was a major terrorist incident or, at the very least, the breaking up of an international crime network.
In reality, the 114 people arrested may be closer to al-Ikea than al Qaida - a self-assembly group of climate change campaigners, planning another protest at the Ratcliffe-on-Soar power station.
The questions that hang in the air are whether the scale of the police operation or the damage they themselves have done justifies the pre-emptive disruption of the protest?
I only happen to know about the damage because my daughter goes to the nursery at the school. Parents were called to say the nursery was closed until further notice.
Doors had been smashed in and glass trodden throughout the carpeted play area. Obviously not a safe environment for the pre-school plotters whose closest connection to direct action might be watercolour painting.
I subsequently discovered that the police had smashed their way in to every part of the school, even though climate change activists were gathered in an unused wing adjacent to the school.
Suddenly it started to look clumsy and heavy-handed; an operation conceived by people who spend too much time watching American police movies. I found myself drawn more to this view after a radio interview in which the police representative justified the pre-emptive arrests on the basis that they saved the police and the energy company considerable cost had the direct action gone ahead.
At this stage none of us knew what the 'action' plans were. Presumably this will all come out in court...if it ever gets to court.
The trouble with the pre-emptive arrests is that you don't have a crime. Nor do the police have much success in getting convictions in such 'conspiracy to trespass' cases. Having been involved in a number of mass trespass activities, I must record that I have had enormous difficulties getting arrested and charged. Most times the police simply told me to push off as they had more important crimes to address. Quite right.
Maybe the power station protesters had something more serious in mind. But if the police had already infiltrated the group, the trick is to catch them in the act.
Only major acts of international terrorism justify pre-emptive arrests. Otherwise we enter the Orwellian world of thought crimes and the closed society. No freedom of assembly. No right to challenge something deeply damaging to society. Everything can be outlawed because of the 'possibility' of violence.
I have no idea what was in the protesters' minds and would certainly offer no blank cheque endorsement of any plan to destroy buildings or take other people's lives.
But on the issue of coal-fired power stations they are right. Their carbon emissions will kill us all.
In the future we will use coal for its chemicals not its combustion. Energy companies know that carbon capture and storage is a delusion. This is why they lobbied so hard to ensure the government did not make this a condition attached to the proposed Kingsnorth power station.
As politicians we do not grasp the urgency of scientific warnings about how little time we have left to radically transform our whole thinking about sustainable energy systems.
Inevitably, this leaves the challenge to be picked up by the public rather than by parliament. In doing so, it just doesn't help if we end up locking up those who would save the planet rather than those who drive us towards climate crises.







8 Comments
by Graham, NG1 4EX
Wednesday, May 27 2009, 12:29AM
“The Key Stone Cops in action.Who ever the senior officers are who planned this debacle....they need dismissing for wasting public money and the miss use of legislation....that was designed to help stop terrorism...”
by Reg, Radford
Monday, May 25 2009, 10:27AM
“"Its an outrage that so much tax payers money has been spent on drafting other forces in from surrounding areas, at a huge cost."
Really ?
I'm sure the costs incurred were far lower than had the police allowed these feeble minded "activists" to break into the power station & occupy it.
Simpson should be ashamed to back such action but he does the same with his support for illegal asylum seekers, undermining our public officials rather than giving them his backing.
The only person to have benefitted from Simpson's tenure as MP for Nottingham South is Simpson himself.
How does his faux concern for climate change and the environement tally with him jetting off to his third home in Tuscany ?
The man's a Chianti Socialist.”
by Zoziebelle, Nottingham
Friday, May 08 2009, 12:16PM
“Well said Alan! Its an outrage that so much tax payers money has been spent on drafting other forces in from surrounding areas, at a huge cost. (find out with the freedom to information act) When in all actuality there is no founded crime to speak of, How do the police plan to prosecute for the possibility of an action? Grace you obviously have no concept of anything that went on, and indeed, rather than listen to the well made and fully justified points that have been made, you choose to critisise on personal points. Clearly making yourself look uneducated and foolish. As stated the people weren't in the school, but in an annex ajacent to the school. As the news reports have stated, the protestors arrived on the evening and arrested the same evening.
I only wish that our MPs for Nottingham east were as much involved within the interests of the voting community as Alan Simpson, rather than issuing no comments and press evasion tactics.”
by grace, carlton
Thursday, April 30 2009, 11:36AM
“plse do not listen to alan simpson who has the highest expenses in nottingham, 3 houses paid for by us, and a daughter at a private nursery which he has put down in the past dont do as i do , do as i say, he forgets to mension that these people were in the school for more than one night.who let them in and what were they doing there they were breaking the law, so Alan Simpson stop advising people to break the law if they do they take the consequences”
by mark pryke, wales
Wednesday, April 15 2009, 3:34PM
“I wish you were my MP, the voice of Future Labour?”
by kaye brennan, nottingham
Wednesday, April 15 2009, 3:15PM
“Alan - thanks for giving some perspective to this 'operation'. Recent similar heavy-handed tactics by the police have resulted in an innocent man's death in London, and while these protestors had every right to be frustrated by our government's lack of leadership on their own policies there was no need for so many police or the behaviour you describe against the Iona school from them. Presumably this independant, charitable school will now have to fork out to repair the damage done by the police.
I think it's worth noting that the group was stopped, no doubt, because it had been infiltrated - either by E-on or by the police.
As a campaigner, I'm not into direct action but I applaud those who had the passion and conviction to take a stand. When all else is failing it seems like this type of action is the only way left to be heard. It seems there's little hope for peaceful protest or even the right to challenge in our so-called 'democracy' anymore.”
by Richard, Halesowen
Wednesday, April 15 2009, 2:55PM
“Alan you are a welcome voice of sanity in the moral desert otherwise known as the House of Commons. If t you apply the logic the police used here to other protests then some of the greatest people of the 20th Century (Mahatma Gandhi, Martin Luther King and so on) would be dismissed as common criminals.
As Gandhi one said ¿First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win¿
Hold on a minute someone in a uniform is knocking down the front door¿”
by Cylon, Ilkeston
Wednesday, April 15 2009, 12:50PM
“I thought about speeding once !! Hey they are outside ! Whats that Red Dot !!.... Silence .........”